When 5-Star Reviews Aren’t Enough: A Cautionary Tale About Rogue Roof Repairs
Colin Frampton • April 30, 2025

We were recently called out to help an elderly lady who had hired a roofer she found on one of the biggest trade checker websites in the UK. He had dozens of glowing 5-star reviews and promised professional repairs. Sadly, what she got was shoddy, unsafe, and downright dangerous.

From the outside, things looked okay—but it only took one heavy storm to reveal the truth. Water came pouring through the ceiling. When we inspected the roof, the extent of the poor workmanship was immediately clear:

  • Loose and missing tiles, with gaps left completely open to the elements
  • Exposed timbers and rotting supports
  • Unsealed flashing and some of the worst lead work we’ve ever seen
  • Ripped and poorly applied felt offering no real protection
  • Zero waterproofing integrity in several key areas


This wasn’t just careless—it was negligent. The photos speak for themselves:

We’ve now made the roof safe and watertight, but the situation should never have happened. It’s a frustrating reminder that even platforms full of 5-star reviews aren’t immune to abuse—and sadly, rogue traders know how to game the system.

A Few Tips to Protect Yourself or Someone Vulnerable:

✅ Check for more than just online reviews – ask for recent local references, ideally from people you know or trust

✅ Look for memberships and trade credentials – like NFRC, TrustMark, or other recognised trade bodies

✅ Ask for before and after photos of previous work

✅ Be cautious of anyone who can “start tomorrow” and those who demand full payment upfront

✅ Talk to friends, neighbours, or family before committing

✅ Make sure they show you the work before paying

This lovely lady was fortunate to have family nearby who noticed something wasn’t right and called us in to help. But not everyone has that safety net. If you know someone elderly or vulnerable who’s planning work on their home, a quick conversation now might save them a lot of stress—and money—later.

We're always happy to offer advice or take a quick look if something doesn’t feel right. No pressure, no obligation. Just honest guidance.

If you’ve had a similar experience—or want to make sure it never happens to you—get in touch with us.


By Colin Frampton April 4, 2025
At Frampton Roofing, we take pride in delivering long-lasting roofing solutions for projects big and small. This recent shed roof is a perfect example of how a simple upgrade can make a big difference.
By Colin Frampton February 27, 2025
At Frampton Roofing, we take pride in restoring and upgrading roofs to the highest standards. Our latest project saw us re-roofing the Margate Mosque , ensuring durability, weather resistance, and a beautifully finished look that will stand the test of time.
By Colin Frampton February 10, 2025
Why Spring is the Perfect Time to Book Your New Flat Roof in Broadstairs